After the midterms vouchers are on the table in Raleigh

Published 46 minutes ago

By Public Ed Works

For supporters of public education, it has been very clear over the past 10-plus years that the Opportunity Scholarships in North Carolina do not provide “opportunities” for all students. In fact, the wealthy have largely benefited from vouchers, particularly once the income cap was eliminated.

While many have worked hard to debunk the myths surrounding vouchers, the reality is that for more than a decade, proposals to limit private school vouchers went nowhere in the General Assembly. The November election changed that. 

Democrats won the state House for the first time since 2010 and broke the Republican supermajority in the Senate. The Opportunity Scholarship program is now a top item on the 2027 agenda. Finally, North Carolina families have the chance to see the millions spent on vouchers return to funding public schools.

How the program grew

Lawmakers created vouchers in 2013 to help lower-income families afford private school. After the 2024 overhaul removed income limits and opened the program to families already in private school, enrollment more than tripled, from about 32,500 students in 2023-24 to more than 106,000 last year. 

That’s nearly three-quarters of the state’s private school students, at a cost of roughly $590 million. As of October, 44% of this year’s 104,000 recipients wouldn’t have qualified under the old income limits.

Republican leaders had planned to raise funding to $700 million for 2027-28, rising eventually to $825 million a year. Meanwhile, participating private schools don’t have to accept students with special needs, provide subsidized lunch, or publish basic information about tuition and outcomes.

What incoming leaders are saying

Incoming Speaker Robert Reives said vouchers will get the same budget scrutiny as everything else the state funds. He called the program a luxury item and said it’s ridiculous for millionaires to get a coupon from the state while public education goes unfunded. 

Reives also said he’s heard from Republicans who think the program has gotten “a little out of hand.”

Greensboro Rep. Amos Quick said the moment offers a chance to “right-set school funding,” though he thinks ending the program outright is unlikely. 

Rep. Tracy Clark of Greensboro supported vouchers early for low-income families but opposed expansion, and she cites schools operating with no accreditation, test verification or teacher credentials.

Possible changes include a moratorium on new awards, reinstated income limits and new reporting rules. A moratorium would let current recipients keep their scholarships while the program phases down over time. 

The State Board of Education and North Carolina Department of Public Instruction (NCDPI) have asked for a moratorium beginning in 2027-28, along with a $35 million public school reinvestment fund.

The Senate decides what’s possible

Republicans are expected to hold a narrow Senate majority, though one undecided race could produce a 25-25 split, with Lt. Gov. Rachel Hunt as the tiebreaker. Any change must pass both chambers, which favors proposals with broad appeal. 

If private schools continue to receive public money, accountability must be connected to the funds they receive. For instance, they should be required to post admissions policies, tuition, teacher licensure, graduation rates and test data so families can compare them with public schools. 

Our view

Governor Stein and public education advocacy groups have urged lawmakers to impose a moratorium. At minimum, any school taking public dollars should meet transparency standards comparable to public schools. 

NCDPI’s facilities survey found $18 billion in building needs over five years, educators still trail the nation in pay, and the new constitutional amendments could constrain revenue further. To put it plainly: families who could already afford private school have been the main beneficiaries of the expansion. 

Ideally, the money currently being spent to fund the wealthy to send their children to private school should go back to public school classrooms where it can benefit more people and fulfill North Carolina’s constitutional mandate to provide “a general and uniform system of free public schools, … and wherein equal opportunities shall be provided for all students.”