Are there any traditional Democrats remaining in NC?

Published January 9, 2015

By Tom Campbell

by Tom Campbell, Executive Producer and Moderator, NC SPIN, January 8, 2015.

Jim Graham, our late Commissioner of Agriculture, used to entertain audiences by braying like a mule, explaining that the mule was not only the symbol of the Democratic Party but also a reminder of our roots as an agricultural state. Democrats have been braying a lot recently, and for all the good its done them they might as well have been braying at the moon.

After a century of being in charge of North Carolina government Democrats despair at being relegated to the backbenches when decisions are made. But enough of the whining already; their crybaby act is making them look like sore-tail losers. It’s time Democrats owned their shortcomings, remembered their roots and started speaking out forcefully and proudly for what they believe.

Both political parties have strayed from their raisin’s, to use a euphemism we all understand. Over the past half century they’ve been hi-jacked and no longer advocate for everyone, instead becoming mouthpieces for certain ones. The GOP has traditionally been more closely aligned with business, but they shifted far right to champion big corporations, the wealthy and elite. Democrats were most often associated with the underdog and the middle-class, but they veered far left to cheerlead the causes of minorities, women and unions.

Let’s be clear. We wouldn’t for one moment suggest that Democrats turn their backs on these groups but they do need to decide if they are more than just evangelists for them.

If the Democrats’ goal is to win elections and regain power they have work to do. They must stop fighting each other and quit “killing the messengers” who proclaim their liberal left shift and insist they return to their more moderate and centrist roots. To win, they must recapture white males and unaffiliated voters. They won’t attract them so long as they are so far left of center.

North Carolina Democrats in the era between the 1930s and 1960s were what you might call “progressive centrists.” They were fiscal conservatives who believed in personal, corporate and government accountability and responsibility. They stood firm for fairness, a level playing field and the common good. Democrats advocated growth, opportunity and a way up for all, espousing working middle class values, because these were the folks who made up the backbone, the majority in our state and nation.

Democrats were also progressives in recognizing that government had a role in improving our lives. They advocated better public schools, wholesome work environments, public safety and the infrastructure that would benefit all. These Democrats demanded their government functioned effectively and be accountable. They were skeptical of big government, big business and big anything, neither supporting high taxes nor unnecessary government interference in their affairs. They believed in giving people a hand up but never intended that help to become unending handouts for anyone.

So what happened to these Democrats? Where are they today? Instead of whining about what they’ve lost why shouldn’t the Democratic Party return to its roots and loudly and proudly proclaim what they do stand for? Where are the leaders, the spokespersons who can articulate this message and rally the party faithful and others wanting something positive to stand for?

Are there any traditional Democrats remaining in North Carolina?

January 9, 2015 at 8:23 am
David Morgan says:

EXCELLENT ARTICLE!!!

I'm a traditional one and the Party needs to get back to being such!!

January 9, 2015 at 10:35 am
Ray Midgett says:

Tom Campbell, you not only hit the nail square on the head, you slammed it tight against the board in one swoope. And your comments explain exactly why this lifetime (72 years) Democrat is now registered Unaffiliated.

January 11, 2015 at 4:11 pm
Charles Malone says:

This article sums up well what any effective political party ought to be doing: advocating for the common good. Both parties are drowning in a sea of special interests-Democrats to the left and Republicans to the right. This political fragmentation is a receipt for fostering an alienated--not engaged-- electorate.

January 20, 2015 at 9:59 am
Chris Telesca says:

I'd say other than a few well-financed left groups (pro-choice reproductive rights and LGBTQ groups), the Democratic Party has been slowly hijacked and moved to the right.

Remember Richard Nixon? We used to think he was a die-hard conservative. Today Nixon couldn't run for President as a Democrat because he'd be too liberal! The Establishment has hijacked both parties - and rank & file Democrats have let them do it. Wake up and smell the economic inequality!

January 9, 2015 at 9:28 am
Frank Burns says:

Part of the blame for the demise of the Democrats has to be the proliferation of all these advocacy groups all wanting more and more things. The only party speaking for the middle class is the GOP.

January 11, 2015 at 6:47 pm
Frank McGuirt says:

The Republicans speak for the middle class? What you been smoking?

January 12, 2015 at 3:04 pm
Frank Burns says:

Cutting spending, jobs, cutting taxes, school choice, etc. I don't the left speaking out in favor of these items. The GOP is the only party standing for the middle class. I've been smoking JR cigars, what have you been smoking?

January 11, 2015 at 10:02 am
Chris Telesca says:

This is a very lame article. There's no way Dems will attract white males - they all watch Fox, own guns, don't like that women and minorities have come up in the world and aren't going back down, vote GOP against their own best economic interests, etc. We saw that with Kay Hagan. How are we going to extend economic benefits to the middle class, but not cheer-lead for unions? How are we going to raise pay across the board for middle class people if we do nothing for unions? Increased union membership means higher pay for the middle class. This guy is a mouthpiece for Establishment business-progressive Dems whose time has come and gone! Which explains why I no longer watch NC Spin - out of touch and out of date!

January 19, 2015 at 10:56 pm
Bert Bowe says:

Mr. Campbell is trying to reinforce stereotypes that haven't been valid for decades: 1. Democrats are too liberal, giving away the store, and 2. both parties "...no longer advocate for everyone, instead becoming mouthpieces for certain ones." Both parties - really? These are red herrings and I say please give us a number of specific examples of what you are talking about!

Fighting for a living wage above $7.25/hour so people can raise a family and pay for basics, especially when the income and asset disparity between the very wealthy and the average person is larger than ever? I mean huge - look at the numbers.

Wanting a decent wage for teachers? Trying to protect the environment from fracking and other pollution? Standing for equal rights for women, gays and minorities - not give-aways, equal opportunities?

Fighting for health care for several hundred thousand North Carolinians via Medicaid?

Here's another specific U.S. example: Republicans in Congress wanted to reduce waste so 6-7 Senators co-sponsored the a deficit reduction committee bill. Later, when President Obama agreed, the same sponsors voted against it! Can't have Obama be seen as successful. Instead, he created that committee (Simpson-Boyles) by executive order to find waste, fraud and abuse in government.

If anything, the Democratic Party has moved too far to the right.