Most people point to polling that shows less than half the voters have a favorable impression of Democrats. That may be true, but it’s driven primarily by Republicans who universally despise Democrats. Democrats overwhelmingly support their party. Independents are skeptical, but that’s their nature. They don’t trust either party, so lukewarm is about as good as it gets.
Two polls taken since the election, an Economist/YouGov poll and a Reuters/Ipsos poll, show Democrats with favorability ratings at about 45% while about 51% view them unfavorably. In both those polls, Republican support for the Democratic Party is in single digits. Around 40% of independents see Democrats favorably and a little over 50% unfavorably. For voters who are wary of both parties, that’s a decent grade.
Republicans, meanwhile, are underwater by about 20 points. Less than 25% of independents have a favorable view of the party, while as much as 70% have an unfavorable view. Republicans are in a deep hole.
Voters look ready to give Democrats a chance to govern. They have strong support from their own party and tacit support from the independents who just broke for them by about 20 points. Voters may be skeptical, but they bet big on Democrats in the midterms and want to see it pay off.
For a party to govern effectively, it needs to bring people along with it, not try to impose its views on the electorate. Right now, Democrats need to earn trust. They should start implementing policies that have broad support. In particular, they need to look at ways to bring prices down.
They don’t need to chase big, ideological objectives yet. They need to show that they can govern first. They can get the mandate they want in 2028 if they’ll be patient now. Keep your eyes on the prize.
Democrats won because a lot of demoralized Republicans stayed home, angry Democrats showed up, and independents broke heavily for the party out of power. Tread softly but decisively. Taking on corruption, billionaires, and corporate cheats will deliver dividends.
As the GOP pollster Cygnal wrote in its post-election analysis:
Voters want the new Congress to crack down on health insurance companies (60%), AI companies (52%), pharmaceutical companies (52%), data centers (51%), and oil and gas companies (48%). Democrats drive most of that demand, especially on AI companies and data centers (69% Dems, 29% GOP). Healthcare is a unique exception in that Republicans (63%) want action taken on insurers and pharma.
Tackling those issues is a full plate for two years. Democrats should notch some wins, show voters they can govern, and build the kind of trust that neither party has been able to sustain for the past decade. That’s the path to bigger, more systemic victories that usher in a needed era of reform.
The 2028 election could be big. Trump may not be on the ballot, but he will still make the election about him. Voters will reward Democrats if they can keep the country from fracturing more and make modest gains in holding corporations accountable and keeping costs down. Like 2006 and 2008, Democrats could get two good election cycles in a row if they just don’t f*%# it up.
Subscribe to Thomas' substack blog here.